With over two decades in SEO, I’ve lived through every major disruption the industry has faced – from focusing on meta keywords to rank in AltaVista to Google’s re-search, to mobile-first indexing, and now AI.
What feels different today is the pace of change and the emotional weight it carries. I see increasing pressure in all groups, even among experienced professionals who have been through all the big changes before this one.
Many have a legitimate concern: If AI can do this quickly, where do I fit in? That is not a technical question. It’s human.
That uncertainty affects morale and adoption. Productivity is slow. Test stalls. Teams overuse AI without judgment or avoid it altogether.
The real leadership challenge is about building confidence, power, and trust in AI-assisted teams.
4 tips for building AI confidence in SEO teams
Building real confidence in AI within the SEO team isn’t about rolling out new tools. It’s about shifting culture.
The most effective SEO teams aren’t the ones that use a lot of tools. They use AI with purpose and discipline. They automate data extraction, summarize research, and cluster keywords. This allows teams to focus on strategy, storytelling, and stakeholder alignment.
The adoption of technology is largely cultural, as Harvard Business School has noted. Tools alone do not drive change. Hope does. That insight applies directly to SEO teams navigating AI today.
Below are four strategies for building AI confidence in your teams through clarity, participation, and shared ownership, not pressure or hype.
1. Gain trust by involving the team in AI tool selection and workflow design
An effective way to build trust from startup to shared ownership. People trust those who help create it.
When the AI is placed in a group, the resistance increases. Inviting people into testing and building workflows makes AI feel less intimidating and empowering. Bringing teams in early also reveals real-world insights where AI mitigates conflict or introduces new risks.
Effective leaders:
- Invite groups to test the tools and share feedback.
- Do small tests before measuring the acquisition.
- Be clear about what you accept, what you reject, and why.
When teams feel included, they are more willing to explore. They learn and tap into new powers. That openness fuels growth and innovation.
Dig deeper: Why SEO teams need to ask ‘should we be using AI?’ not just ‘can we?’
2. Meet people where they are – not where you want them to be
The power of AI varies greatly across SEO teams. Some doctors check every day. Others feel overwhelmed or skeptical, often because they have seen past automation trends come and go.
Self-confident leaders understand that ability grows at different speeds. They create environments that encourage curiosity, where uncertainty is normal, and learning happens continuously, not just when mandated.
That means:
- Adapting to different comfort levels.
- Creating mental safety about “I don’t know yet.”
- To avoid embarrassment or over-celebration of those who were first received.
- It offers many ways to learn.
Seeing different starting points makes progress feel more attainable than threatening.
Your customers are searching everywhere. Make sure it’s your product he appears.
The SEO toolkit you know, and the AI visibility data you need.
Start a Free Trial
Start with
3. Celebrate the winners and highlight the champions
Confidence grows with visible success.
When someone uses AI to cut a job from hours to minutes, it’s more than a productivity gain. It proves that AI can support real work without replacing human judgment.
Working groups:
- Share clear examples of AI improving quality and efficiency.
- Highlight internal champions who can mentor others.
- Create a space for demos and information sharing.
- Foster a culture of evaluation, not judgment.
My agency is building AI-focused teams with members from across the organization. One group focused on integrating AI into project management, with representatives from SEO, operations, and leadership.
That shared ownership made the acquisition very successful. The teams weren’t just making AI; they were shaping how it fits into the actual workflow. The result was stronger buy-in, better collaboration, and greater confidence across the team.
Each group shared their successes and lessons learned. This builds awareness of what worked and why. Momentum builds when teams see their peers using AI responsibly and effectively.
Dig deep: The future of SEO teams is people-led and agent-powered
4. Frame AI as a collaborative partner, not a replacement
The fear of being replaced is real. Ignoring it doesn’t make it go away. Teams need to be clear about where human expertise is still important.
Reframing AI as a partner means emphasizing:
- AI handles the volume. People handle nuances.
- AI accelerates analysis. People interpret meaning.
- AI draft. People confirm, refine and balance.
- AI measures your output. People build trust and influence.
AI can help with practice, but it cannot replace strategic intuition, contextual judgment, or diverse leadership. Those are the skills that ultimately lead to performance.
Why information still matters in AI-driven SEO
AI has lowered the barrier to entry for many SEO jobs. With the right information, almost anyone can generate a keyword list, outline, or summary. With that reach, we see a lot of short-term tactics and “quick wins” recycled.
Anyone who has been in SEO long enough has seen this cycle before. Tactics change. The basics don’t. This is where experience makes the difference.
AI can produce output, not accountability
AI can generate content and analyze data, but it has no results. It bears no responsibility for product reputation, compliance, or long-term performance.
SEO professionals are always responsible for:
- Deciding what to exclude from publication.
- Assessing technical risk, reputation, and compliance.
- Weighing long-term effects against short-term benefits.
AI is working. People decide. That distinction is more important than ever.
Pattern recognition is learned, not automatic
AI excels at surface patterns. It is difficult to explain why they are important or applicable in a particular context.
Experienced SEOs bring a depth of understanding that AI cannot replicate. Their historical background helps them separate real shifts from industry noise.
Few industries have seen as many rise and fall tactics as SEO. Experience makes logical thinking more than what worked before and helps to avoid repeating strategies that once worked but later failed.
AI raises the possibility. The feeling is checking the compatibility.
Professional integrity is always the difference
In highly visible search conditions, errors increase rapidly. AI can produce false objects and hallucinations. These mistakes can put brands at risk of losing trust and facing compliance issues.
Groups with strong SEO basics:
- Validate AI output instead of assuming correctness.
- Prioritize accuracy over speed.
- Maintain SEO ethical standards.
- Protect the brand’s word and credibility.
Loyalty does not happen. It gets used to it. In a high-speed AI environment, that behavior is even more important.
Dig deep: How to build and lead a successful remote SEO team
Optimizing SEO in the AI era
AI accelerates SEO.
As mundane tasks become automated, the role of SEO experts shifts to strategic oversight. Time once spent on manual analysis can be redirected to interpreting user intent, shaping search strategy, targeting stakeholders, and assessing risk.
This makes the basics very important. Parties still require sound judgment, technical knowledge, and accountability. AI can support execution, but experts remain responsible for decisions, quality, and long-term performance.
Developing the next generation of SEOs requires more than knowing the tools. Need to teach:
- When to trust AI.
- When does it challenge.
- How to use information and context in your output.
Contributing writers are invited to create content for Search Engine Land and are selected for their expertise and contribution to the search community. Our contributors work under the supervision of editorial staff and contributions are assessed for quality and relevance to our students. Search Engine Land is owned by Semrush. The contributor has not been asked to speak directly or indirectly about Semrush. The opinions they express are their own.
